Are seed paper cards better for the environment than Clards? They do different jobs. Seed paper cards are planted once. Clards replace paper towels for months, then compost. The better pick is the one your recipient will actually use.
You want to send a card, not more trash. Good news: you have options. Two of the most popular eco-friendly greeting cards are plantable seed paper cards and Clards®, greeting cards that turn into reusable cleaning cloths. Both beat a glitter card that heads straight to the landfill. Here's how they compare.
The quick version
| Seed paper cards | Clards® | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Paper with seeds pressed inside | A greeting card that turns into reusable, washable, compostable cleaning cloths |
| After it's read | Plant it | Use it in the kitchen |
| How long it's useful | One planting | Months of everyday use |
| What it needs | Soil, sun, the right season | A sink |
| Best for | Gardeners, spring and summer occasions | Anyone with a kitchen, any time of year |
| End of life | Grows into flowers or herbs | Compostable |
Seed paper cards: what they do well
Seed paper cards are made from recycled paper with wildflower or herb seeds pressed right in. After the card is read, you plant it, water it, and (with some luck) watch it bloom. They're a sweet idea, widely available, and a great fit for the gardener in your life, especially around spring birthdays, Mother's Day, or a sympathy card that grows into something lasting.
The catch: they depend on timing and a green thumb. A seed card that arrives in December in Minnesota is waiting a long time for planting season. And if the recipient doesn't garden, it often lands in a drawer, which is where most cards go to retire anyway.
Clards: the card that cleans up
I came up with Clards while standing in the greeting card aisle, annoyed about paying $8 to $15 for a card that would end up in the trash. I remembered a paper-like cleaning cloth my daughter had given me and thought: why can't the card be the cloth?
So that's what a Clard is. Write your message, send it, and after it's read it turns into reusable, washable, compostable cleaning cloths. One Clard does the work of up to 3,000 paper towels. Designs are printed with plant-based inks, and when it's worn out after months of use, it's compostable. I like to put chop them up in my plants to hold moisture.
No garden required. No waiting for spring. Just a kitchen, which, last we checked, most people have.
Which one should you send?
Send a seed paper card if:
- Your recipient loves to garden
- It's spring or early summer
- You want a gift that grows
Send a Clard if:
- It's the holidays (or any season, really)
- Your recipient "doesn't need anything" (they need a cloth, trust us)
- You want the card itself to be the gift
- You'd like your greeting to hang around the kitchen for months instead of a week on the fridge
Why not both?
Honestly, any card that skips the landfill is a win. Seed paper grows something. Clards clean something. Pick the one that fits the person, and feel good about either.
But if you want a card that gets used every single day, we might be a little biased.
Quick answers
Are seed paper cards better for the environment than Clards? They do different jobs. Seed paper cards are planted once. Clards replace paper towels for months, then compost. The better pick is the one your recipient will actually use.
Can you plant a Clard? No, but you can compost it when it's worn out. But you can put it in your plants to help hold a little moisture between watering.
What's the most eco-friendly greeting card? One that doesn't end up in the trash. Reusable cards like Clards and plantable seed paper cards are two of the best options.
Get 20% Off Your First Order
Join our community and get eco-friendly tips, new designs, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.